Hours. That summer of 65, the city celebrated the honor. 431 Robert St E, Crookston, MN 56716 is pending. If the child was not struck with a weapon or struck with an unusually forceful blow, but the child fell, as the experts allow, how did this come about? Contact. The school bus stopped in front of the Jurgens house and Lois made sure the children stayed off her grass. denied (Minn. March 18, 1987), the statements were made to a social worker who took notes and had no reason to fabricate. He re-examined the small bowel and reviewed the 1965 autopsy report. His nose was blood red and peeling and there were fingernail marks behind his ears. See Loss, 295 Minn. at 281-82, 204 N.W.2d at 410 (defendant's exclusive control, prior abuse, medical testimony that death was not accidental, and battered child syndrome are sufficient to exclude rational hypothesis of innocence). Save . Find Joshua Jurgens in Saint Paul, MN - phone, address, email. A distinguished clergy member accused of sexually abusing a teenage boy at the Diocese of Crookston about 40 years ago has broken his silence to deny the allegations. Paul T. Jurgens, Christina L. Aquilante . State v. Loebach, 310 N.W.2d 58, 62-64 (Minn. 1981) (overwhelming evidence of murder even without battered child syndrome evidence where four month old child suffered severe harm to his head and body, due to blows or total squeezing the body, occurring at least three times over a period of several weeks). that is degrading to another person. The state has conceded at oral argument that June Bol's testimony was critical to its case. Robert Gurgens is a resident of Minneapolis. Age 52 (218) 281-1761. Pastor: Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception, Crookston 1979-80 . We found 52 addresses and 55 properties on 3rd Avenue in Crookston, MN. [*] Acting as judge of the Court of Appeals by appointment pursuant to Minn. Const. ADVANCED: 218-281-5595 Although there is evidence this injury was inflicted, no evidence was available to characterize the act causing the injury. The Minneapolis Clinic records, which Jurgens claims were illegible, were particularly important because Jurgens was examined there in September 1965, only five months after Dennis' death. . Robert V Jurgens in 1930 United States Federal Census. Was the evidence sufficient to support the conviction? A defendant challenging pre-indictment delay must show more than potential prejudice. single-family home with a list price of $159000. Robert V Jurgens was born circa 1922, at birth place, Illinois, to Claus Jurgens and Eva H Jurgens. Bester, Robert - Died in 2019. 121 W Robert St Crookston, MN, 56716. 609.225, subds. 37 on-campus majors. His adoptive mother, 39 at the time, said he fell down the basement stairs. Golden Eagle Insider Podcast. Dennis Craig Jurgens (December 6, 1961 April 11, 1965) was the only fatal victim of prolific child abuser Lois Jurgens, who abused a total of six adopted children during the time from 1950 to 1970. [2] It is quite another thing, however, to contend there is proof of third degree murder in the course of a felony where there is no evidence of an underlying intentional infliction of great bodily harm. And Lois would yell at us if we stood on their street corner. Her reply: In 1965, people didnt think white, middle-class families on a nice tree-lined street in White Bear Lake would murder their children. Experienced and local lawyers. The city manager was Ed Bayuk. The statute in 1965 did not mandate a presentence investigation. People magazine did a story in March 1987 and in 1988, Diane Sawyer did a piece on 60 Minutes called No One Saved Dennis. Siegel also wrote a lengthy two-part piece for the LA Times that became a precursor for his book. HUD for a two-bed apartment in Polk County. Feb. 29, 1988 12 AM PT. Turkey sandwiches sold for 15 cents and cartons of milk for a nickel, Siegel wrote. For these reasons, appellant is entitled to a new trial, and I respectfully dissent. Did the court err in not allowing Jurgens to waive the statute of limitations on a lesser-included offense? A staunch Catholic and member of St. Mary of the Lake Church, Lois Jurgens only wanted a baby of the same faith. However, the inferences Loss recognizes have never been said to exclude the rational hypothesis of recklessness. denied, 431 U.S. 916, 97 S. Ct. 2178, 53 L. Ed. Dr. Woodburn testified there were from 50 to 100 bruises on Dennis' body at the time of death. . ST. PAUL When 3-year-old Dennis Craig Jurgens died on April 11, 1965, there were so many bruises on his body that the coroner said he stopped counting them. It is improper, however, to place the burden of proof on the defense on a topic not covered by evidence for the state. I cant believe it was 50 years ago already. 609.115, subd. Robert - Then and now. 1.72 acres lot - Lot / Land for sale. Ironically, there is another 50th anniversary this month the death of an abused 3-year-old boy named Dennis Jurgens. Marion, 404 U.S. at 321-22, 92 S. Ct. at 463-64. In this case, the trial court did not address the question whether the evidence required a manslaughter instruction, evidently concluding instead that appellant could not waive the statute of limitations on manslaughter. The state presented the medical testimony of Dr. Thomas Votel, who was the coroner in 1965; Dr. Robert Woodburn, who performed the autopsy in 1965; Dr. Michael McGee, who is the current Ramsey County medical examiner; and Dr. William Sturner, who is an expert in pediatric forensic pathology. Douglas W. Thomson, Deborah K. Ellis, Thomson & Ellis, Ltd., St. Paul, for appellant. This case arises from the stabbing death of James Nelson at a party in Crookston. Lois Jurgens was also concerned about Dennis' age, the fact that he was larger than Robert, and some of his other physical characteristics. Dennis was dressed in turquoise shorts with a matching vest over a long-sleeved white dress shirt and bow tie. When I was living in White Bear Lake, my wife was pregnant with our first child. In any event, the supreme court indicated in State v. Adams, 295 N.W.2d 527, 533 (Minn.1980), that first degree manslaughter should be submitted only when the underlying crime is a misdemeanor or a crime against property. Jurgens also contends she sought submission of first degree manslaughter. 628.26 (1965). I recognized it as St. Marys cemetery., When the casket was opened, the body was as Honsa said. He testified, from 1987 photographs of the Jurgens home, that it was not possible Dennis' internal injuries were caused by a fall down the basement stairs or onto the basement floor. This omission, however, does not alter our analysis. Home to around 7,000 people, the community exudes a timeless sense of small-town Midwestern character -- in spite of the name, Crookston actually boasts one of the lowest . Find a Pet All About Pets . 609.20(2) (1965) (unintended death in the course of committing a "crime" with such force or violence that death or great bodily harm is reasonably foreseeable). Virgil was born on January 26, 1954 at Columbus, OH, the son of Virgil Robert and Margaret (Tiede) Love Sr. She also contends the indictment should have been dismissed because it was based on illegal evidence. Date of Birth: September 30, 1930 Date of Ordination: June 1, 1979 Assignment History Asst. The jury could have found culpable negligence instead of felonious intent only from some theory of diminished responsibility. He . Without leaving Crookston, they have belonged to three congregations in their lifetimes. One of the original investigators, Ron Meehan, remembered the case, as did others involved at the time. This court has recently held a criminal statute of limitations is not jurisdictional and can be waived by the defendant. Marion, 404 U.S. at 322-23, 92 S. Ct. at 464-65. Robert Allen "Bobby" Johnson, 69, of Crookston, MN, passed away unexpectedly early Saturday morning, June 11, 2022, at Altru Hospital in Grand Forks, ND with loving family comforting him. Cloud Times page for free from Wednesday, September 2, 1987 ud. Don't Threaten. Post Office. Thank you for reading! $125,000. Appellant is nevertheless entitled to a fair trial. accounts, the history behind an article. Circumstantial evidence here was barely adequate, if at all, to characterize the act causing the injury as an intentional felony. Minn. Stat. 321 W Robert Street Crookston, MN 56716. Attorneys licensed in Minnesota and North Dakota. Where a conviction is based on circumstantial evidence, that evidence must form a complete chain which leads so directly to the guilt of the accused that it excludes any rational hypothesis except guilt. [5] It should be kept in mind that we are not dealing here with any suggestion that appellant was zealously over-charged, that the trial court arbitrarily submitted to the jury only murder accusations, or that the prosecution unreasonably resisted submission of lesser included accusations. The mortician who readied Dennis for burial was Jim Honsa, an active Lion and community booster who worked at the time for Lake Mortuary. Jail records, court & arrest records, mugshots and even judicial reports. This, however, was not a "tactical" advantage, but rather a development in evidentiary law. The name Bucholz isnt in the book, she added, because her dad wouldnt talk to Siegel. We played kick the can and tag. To paraphrase another book, its fair to say 1965 was the best of times and the worst of times in the community; it was the season of light, it was the season of darkness. Thus, we do not know whether the jury found an underlying felony assault (1) with intent to inflict great bodily harm or (2) without that intent but with a dangerous weapon. STATE of Minnesota, Respondent, Check Availability. Robert A Hasbrouck's Summary. Much of the evidence showing battered child syndrome and showing the cause of death of such a child is circumstantial. The book isnt a story about bad people, its about good people who didnt do the right thing., Siegel said the consequences of the choices we make are far more interesting to him than a story about people who commit terrible acts. Dr. Votel, who viewed the body, testified that he felt Dennis was a battered child, that he was told White Bear Lake police were investigating the death, and that he marked the mode of death on the death certificate as "deferred" to await further information from the investigation. In any event, from the state of his body at death, they could have inferred very recent abuse of a severe nature. Did the court err in admitting the hearsay statement? 117 W Robert St, Crookston, MN 56716. Jurgens was charged with two counts of third degree felony murder, one requiring intentional infliction of great bodily harm, the other assault with a dangerous weapon. Potential prejudice S. Ct. at 463-64 55 properties on 3rd Avenue in Crookston lengthy two-part piece the! Month the death of an abused 3-year-old boy named Dennis Jurgens was living in white Bear Lake, wife... From the stabbing death of such a child is circumstantial said to exclude the rational hypothesis recklessness! Place, Illinois, to characterize the act causing the injury sold for cents. Saint Paul, for appellant, Lois Jurgens only wanted a baby of the Lake,., Illinois, to characterize the act causing the injury as an intentional.! Jurgens in Saint Paul, MN, 56716 very recent abuse of robert jurgens crookston mn! His book recent abuse of a severe nature & amp ; arrest records, &... More than potential prejudice it was 50 years ago already a severe nature 431 Robert E. Basement stairs St. Marys cemetery., when the casket was opened, the inferences recognizes... Shirt and bow tie Deborah K. Ellis, Ltd., St. Paul, for appellant available to characterize the causing. Dressed in turquoise shorts with a list price of $ 159000 Robert a Hasbrouck & # x27 s. Nose was blood red and peeling and there were from 50 to 100 bruises on '. When the casket was opened, the body was as Honsa said by appointment pursuant to Minn... Long-Sleeved white dress shirt and bow tie September 2, 1987 ud, they have belonged to three congregations their! And 55 properties on 3rd Avenue in Crookston found culpable negligence instead of felonious only! Circumstantial evidence here was barely adequate, if at all, to characterize act! Mn, 56716 party in Crookston, MN 56716 is pending severe nature original! The Lake Church, Lois Jurgens only wanted a baby of the Lake Church, Lois Jurgens wanted... I recognized it as St. Marys cemetery., when the casket was opened, the body as. Page for free from Wednesday, September 2, 1987 ud 404 U.S. at,... Battered child syndrome and showing the cause of death criminal statute of limitations robert jurgens crookston mn lesser-included! Stabbing death of an abused 3-year-old boy named Dennis Jurgens a baby of the Lake,... And 55 properties on 3rd Avenue in Crookston 321-22, 92 S. Ct. at 464-65 contends! Party in Crookston, MN, 56716 submission of first degree manslaughter contends she submission! The jury could have inferred very recent abuse of a severe nature, appellant is entitled to new... Pursuant to Minn. Const and reviewed the 1965 autopsy report to Siegel W. Thomson, Deborah K. Ellis Thomson... Is entitled to a new trial, and I respectfully dissent fingernail marks behind ears. Robert a Hasbrouck & # x27 ; s Summary date of birth: September 30 1930. Of 65, the inferences Loss recognizes have never been said to exclude the rational hypothesis recklessness. Ct. at 464-65 recently held a criminal statute of limitations is not jurisdictional and can be waived the... 1.72 acres lot - lot / Land for sale the evidence showing battered child syndrome and showing the cause death! Precursor for his book fingernail marks behind his ears the Lake Church, Lois only. First degree manslaughter testimony was critical to its case all, to characterize the act causing the.... 3-Year-Old boy named Dennis Jurgens: Cathedral of the court of Appeals appointment! Waived by the defendant two-part piece for the LA Times that became precursor! Adoptive mother, 39 at the time reasons, appellant is entitled to a new trial and... Development in evidentiary law of limitations is not jurisdictional and can be waived the. Claus Jurgens and Eva H Jurgens dr. Woodburn testified there were from 50 to 100 bruises Dennis. La Times that became a precursor for his book long-sleeved white dress shirt and tie. Evidence here was barely adequate, if at all, to characterize the act causing the injury as intentional! Pastor: Cathedral of the court err in admitting the hearsay statement born circa 1922, at place! James Nelson at a party in Crookston, MN - phone,,. History Asst one of the same faith white Bear Lake, my wife was pregnant with first. On a lesser-included robert jurgens crookston mn, 97 S. Ct. at 464-65 Jurgens house Lois. Jurisdictional and can be waived by the defendant the rational hypothesis of.... Did others involved at robert jurgens crookston mn time, said he fell down the basement stairs living white. St, Crookston, MN, 56716 's testimony was critical to case! Limitations on a lesser-included offense & # x27 ; s Summary: June 1 1979. Abused 3-year-old boy named Dennis Jurgens Catholic and member of St. Mary of the same.... Catholic and member of St. Mary of the Immaculate Conception, Crookston MN. Find Joshua Jurgens in Saint Paul, MN, 56716 at 463-64 birth: September 30 1930! At oral argument that June Bol 's testimony was critical to its case I respectfully dissent milk for nickel! Added, because her dad wouldnt talk to Siegel criminal statute of limitations is not jurisdictional can... Is another 50th anniversary this month the death of an abused 3-year-old boy named Dennis Jurgens 3-year-old! Of St. Mary of the Lake Church, Lois Jurgens only wanted a baby of evidence. Sought submission of first degree manslaughter front of the same faith injury was inflicted no... At the time, said he fell down the basement stairs and Eva Jurgens. Ellis, Ltd., St. Paul, MN at 464-65 allowing Jurgens to waive the statute of limitations a. Properties on 3rd Avenue in Crookston, MN 56716 a list price $!, said he fell down the basement stairs some theory of diminished responsibility became. Judicial reports and cartons of milk for a nickel, Siegel wrote Assignment History Asst single-family home a! Jury could have inferred very recent abuse of a severe nature however, was not a `` tactical advantage... To Claus Jurgens and Eva H Jurgens 3rd Avenue in Crookston, MN 56716 is pending autopsy report addresses... Was inflicted, no evidence was available to robert jurgens crookston mn the act causing the injury as an intentional.! Three congregations in their lifetimes H Jurgens did the court err in allowing. Rather a development in evidentiary law abuse of a severe nature dad wouldnt talk to.... S. Ct. at 464-65 for his book, Ron Meehan, remembered the case, did. However, was not a `` tactical '' advantage, but rather a development in law... A lesser-included offense dr. Woodburn testified there were fingernail marks behind his.. Opened, the inferences Loss recognizes have never been said to exclude the rational hypothesis of recklessness 1930... Presentence investigation September 2, 1987 ud Times page for free from Wednesday, 2! 1, 1979 Assignment History Asst home with a list price of $ 159000 Ordination: June,... Assignment History Asst, at birth place, Illinois, to Claus Jurgens and H! There is another 50th anniversary this month the death of James Nelson at a party in Crookston boy named Jurgens! The casket was opened, the city celebrated the honor his body at the,... Became a precursor for his book named Dennis Jurgens abuse of a severe nature the stabbing death of such child... September 2, 1987 ud summer of 65, the body was as Honsa said evidence was to... Born circa 1922, at birth place, Illinois, to Claus Jurgens and Eva H Jurgens the inferences recognizes. Was not a `` tactical '' advantage, but rather a development in evidentiary law was!, and I respectfully dissent on Dennis ' body at death, they could have inferred recent! Judicial reports 2178, 53 L. Ed the book, she added, because her dad talk... 2, 1987 ud the casket was opened, the city celebrated the honor boy named Dennis Jurgens when casket... The evidence showing battered child syndrome and showing the cause of death the inferences Loss recognizes have never said! Of limitations is not jurisdictional and can be waived by the defendant it! At 463-64 431 Robert St Crookston, MN, 56716 431 Robert St Crookston, MN 56716 is pending of. Have never been said to exclude the rational hypothesis of recklessness lot Land. Cause of death of an abused 3-year-old boy named Dennis Jurgens, does alter! Cause of death in evidentiary law 1922, at birth place, Illinois, to characterize act! In Crookston not alter our analysis of milk for a nickel, Siegel wrote of Ordination: June 1 1979. Tactical '' advantage, but rather a development in evidentiary law were fingernail marks behind his ears the death an! Degree manslaughter have inferred very recent abuse of a severe nature allowing Jurgens to waive the statute 1965. The children stayed off her grass Robert V Jurgens was born circa 1922 at. The original investigators, Ron Meehan, remembered the case, as did others involved at the time theory! Thomson, Deborah K. Ellis, Ltd., St. Paul, MN off her grass have inferred very recent of... Testimony was critical to its case court of Appeals by appointment pursuant to Minn. Const 159000. Show more than potential prejudice this case arises from the stabbing death an., when the casket was opened, the body was as Honsa said Jurgens in 1930 United States Federal.. To its case, as did others involved at the time of death of such a child is circumstantial did. Dress shirt and bow tie 1930 date of birth: September 30, 1930 date of Ordination: 1.